Cannes ignored its best defense against disinformation - the local media
- Israel Mirsky is the executive director of global technology and emerging platforms for OMD Worldwide.
- In this opinion piece, he writes that at Cannes Lions this year, conversations around fake news, misinformation, disinformation, brand safety, and a crisis in consumer trust are rapidly gathering momentum.
- But there's a critical stakeholder missing from the discussion - local and regional independent media, which has a vital role to play in a fragmented society and media landscape.
- This shortsightedness represents a serious missed opportunity to engage all brands and agencies in a meaningful - and actionable - discussion about corporate social responsibility in the act of media planning.
- Visit Business Insider's homepage for more stories.
At Cannes this year, the ad industry's leading voices are discussing their responsibility to society and the issues swirling at the intersection of news and and advertising. Conversations around the safety of children on major platforms, fake news, misinformation, disinformation, brand safety and a crisis in consumer trust are rapidly gathering momentum, most notably in the launch of the Global Alliance for Responsible Media. The alliance of major clients, all five major advertising holding companies, and the major platforms calls for more collective responsibility in media practices, including "working towards a media environment where hate speech, bullying and disinformation is challenged, where personal data is protected, and used responsibly when given, and where everyone, especially children, are better protected from harm."
However, one critical stakeholder hasn't been invited to this table yet. Local and regional independent media has a vital role to play in our fragmented society and media landscape. Independent media and its important oversight and accountability function is in retreat around the world, a decline that closely tracks the global decline in democracy. The US has lost more than 1,800 newspapers since 2004 and one in three Facebook users live in an area without a significant amount of local news coverage. This decline has been most profound for local, independent, community and investigative journalism.
When we lose independent media, especially at the local and regional levels, the costs to democracy, social cohesion and free enterprise are serious:
- Rapid rise in corruption. It has never been a better time to be a corrupt local mayor almost anywhere in the world.
- Drop in civic engagement. Without trusted local news voting rates drop, people join civic organizations in lower numbers and are less likely to run for office
- Disaffection, alienation and anger rises when people don't feel their voices are heard
- Societal polarization rises as people lose less biased local sources and turn primarily to national news which, even the best, tend to have voices on the opinion pages that sort people into filter bubbles.
- Trust. While media is the least trusted institution globally, local media is the most trusted. When people trust their local media, important externalities are created that help build trust in institutions more broadly.
Given the stakes, the topic should have been among the 10 key themes that drove the Cannes agenda this year. But on the list that included such retread and worn out topics such as "winning in the digital economy" or "creating exceptional consumer experiences," an issue that is such a clear and present threat to a stable society didn't merit a slot.
This shortsightedness represents a serious missed opportunity to engage all brands and agencies in a meaningful - and actionable - discussion about corporate social responsibility in the act of media planning. After all, the advertising revenue for which local media are starving is in our shared control.
The topic didn't go totally unaddressed, thanks to the presence of an organization called United for News - a multi-stakeholder coalition of brands, agencies (including OMD), ad tech, media, NGOs and policy makers with a mission to support and sustain reputable media. One of UFN's key initiatives is to reinvigorate the commercial engine for reputable journalism, in part by making it easier for advertisers to purchase inventory from reputable local and regional media. At an off-stage panel that included representatives from OMD, Group M and AppNexus, UFN managing director Tom Jenen moderated a session on how brands can use their budgets to support quality journalism, robust democracies and healthy societies without sacrificing ad performance.
The UFN approach begins with a jointly decided set of criteria for reputable independent media that marries advertising and journalism best practices. Based on these criteria, UFN identify reputable media at all levels of the market - from local to national - and through a private marketplace, make it easy for brands to spend on vetted, quality inventory from independent media. It's a win for brands who want to avoid supporting extremism, propaganda, hate speech and other unintended consequences and actively support reputable media. And it is a win for good journalism.
And that brings up back to another topic on the list of Cannes 2019 themes - trust. This year's agenda was inundated with sessions about regaining consumer trust. One lost, trust is very hard to reclaim. Working to rebuild that trust from the ground up, through making media planning decisions that support and engage with the independent local and regional media that the public trust most, is an opportunity for all brands considering their corporate social responsibility - and a critical long term investment in society that will pay dividends in the form of stability, economic growth and, ultimately, the brand bottom line.
Israel Mirsky is the executive director of global technology and emerging platforms for OMD Worldwide.
This is an opinion column. The thoughts expressed are those of the author.